Adults 18+ only. We earn a commission from some links, but it never changes a score.How we test →
  • Secrets AI: #6 in our ranking
  • Janitor AI: #10 in our ranking
  • Adults 18+

Secrets AI vs Janitor AI (2026): Which Is Better?

Quick verdict

Secrets AI, for most people. As of October 2026, it scores 8.1/10 and Janitor AI 7.8/10. Pick Secrets AI if you want adult chat with pictures. Pick Janitor AI if you want free text roleplay with lots of characters.

Janitor AI has the better price value (8.7). For selfies and romance, Candy.ai (8.7) is the easier start.

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. A commission never changes a score.

8.1out of 10
Secrets AIBuilt for open adult chat#6 of 16 in our ranking
7.8out of 10
Janitor AIBuilt for free character roleplay#10 of 16 in our ranking
Secrets AI and Janitor AI at a glance
At a glanceSecrets AIJanitor AI
Best scoreNSFW freedom, 9.3NSFW freedom, 9.2
Weakest scoreVoice, 6.9Voice, 5.2
PriceFrom $19.99/mo, or $9.17/mo yearlyFree, or $12.99/mo for Janitor+
Free20 messages a dayUnlimited chats, standard models
PicturesFrom 50 moments eachNo picture maker listed
Voice calls50 moments a minuteNone listed
Comparison cardSecrets AI and Janitor AI side by side: the Secrets AI character builder on top and the Janitor AI home page below, real screenshots from each site's public pages
Real screens of Secrets AI’s character builder (top) and Janitor AI’s home page (bottom), captured October 2026.
On this page

Secrets AI vs Janitor AI in 30 seconds

  • Overall: Secrets AI wins, 8.1 to 7.8, as of October 2026. They’re #6 and #10 of 16 in our ranking.
  • Secrets AI wins: pictures (8.4 vs 5.8), voice (6.9 vs 5.2) and app design (8.1 vs 7.0). It also edges ahead on privacy info, customization, mobile and NSFW freedom.
  • Janitor AI wins: price value (8.7 vs 7.4) and chat realism (8.6 vs 8.3). They tie on memory.
  • Real cost: about $12–22 a month on Secrets AI if you mostly chat, and about $0–13 on Janitor AI, from our September 2026 test.
  • Skip both if: you want real voice calls. Kindroid (8.8 for voice) is our pick for voice calls.

Scores side by side: who wins what?

Secrets AI wins 7 of the ten ratings and Janitor AI wins 2; they tie on memory. Secrets AI’s ten ratings work out to 8.09, shown as 8.1. Janitor AI’s work out to 7.78, shown as 7.8. A commission never changes a score.

Secrets AI and Janitor AI scores by rating, out of 10
What we rateWeightSecrets AIJanitor AIHigher score
Overall score8.1 (higher)7.8Secrets AI
Chat realism20%8.38.6 (higher)Janitor AI
Customization12%8.2 (higher)8.0Secrets AI
NSFW freedom12%9.3 (higher)9.2Secrets AI
Memory12%7.6 (tie)7.6 (tie)Tie
Pictures and video10%8.4 (higher)5.8Secrets AI
Price value10%7.48.7 (higher)Janitor AI
App design8%8.1 (higher)7.0Secrets AI
Mobile6%7.8 (higher)7.6Secrets AI
Privacy info5%7.6 (higher)7.2Secrets AI
Voice5%6.9 (higher)5.2Secrets AI

Scores out of 10, October 2026. The higher score in each row is in bold pink. Same scores and weights as our ranking and methodology.

Which is better for pictures?

Secrets AI. It scores 8.4 for pictures and video against 5.8 for Janitor AI.

  • Secrets AI8.4
  • Janitor AI5.8

On Secrets AI, a picture costs from 50 moments, or 100 in 2K, Secrets AI says. On Premium and up, you can turn a picture into a short clip, most 4 to 15 seconds long, its wiki says.

On Janitor AI, you chat by text. Neither of its plans lists a picture maker, its subscription FAQ shows. In our test, it trailed Candy.ai, Nectar AI and OurDream AI for pictures and selfies.

Test it: On Secrets AI, make one picture and one short video. Then check how many moments you have left.

Which is better for your budget?

Janitor AI. It scores 8.7 for price value against 7.4 for Secrets AI.

  • Secrets AI7.4
  • Janitor AI8.7

Janitor AI’s free plan has unlimited chats, standard chat models and a context limit of around 9,000 tokens, its subscription FAQ says. In our test, two of three free characters stayed in character for 30+ turns. Janitor+ costs $12.99 a month in the US App Store.

Secrets AI’s free plan gives you 20 messages a day. Premium costs $19.99 a month and includes 8,000 moments for extras. In our test, mostly chatting cost about $12–22 a month on Secrets AI, against about $0–13 on Janitor AI.

Test it: Open three Janitor AI characters on the free plan in one evening. Keep the one that stays in character for 30 turns.

Which is better for voice?

Secrets AI, though both are weak here. It scores 6.9 for voice against 5.2 for Janitor AI.

  • Secrets AI6.9
  • Janitor AI5.2

Secrets AI has real-time calls at 50 moments a minute, with no time limit, it says. Janitor AI’s plans don’t list voice calls.

For real voice calls, Kindroid (8.8 for voice) is our pick for voice calls.

Test it: Make one 2-minute call on Secrets AI, then check your balance. It should be about 100 moments lower.

Which is better for ease of use?

Secrets AI. It scores 8.1 for app design against 7.0 for Janitor AI.

  • Secrets AI8.1
  • Janitor AI7.0

On Secrets AI, you chat with ready-made companions or build your own. Story reels let you watch her story in a video feed, then pick your first reply. In our test, the delete option was findable, but not one tap away.

Janitor AI feels like a character directory, not a girlfriend app. In its phone app, NSFW is off at first, and you switch it on from the website, its help center says. In our test, that step was easy to miss.

Test it: Using Janitor AI’s phone app? Switch on “Enable NSFW for App” in the website’s Settings, then close the app and open it again.

Secrets AI vs Janitor AI pricing: which costs less?

Secrets AI Premium costs $19.99 a month. Janitor AI is free, and Janitor+ costs $12.99 a month in the US App Store. In our test, mostly chatting cost about $12–22 a month on Secrets AI and about $0–13 on Janitor AI. Confirm prices at checkout: they change.

Secrets AI and Janitor AI prices
Plans and costsSecrets AIJanitor AI
Free20 messages a day and a small starting balance of moments; you can’t buy moreUnlimited chats, standard chat models and a context limit of around 9,000 tokens
MonthlyPremium: $19.99 a monthJanitor+: $12.99 a month in the US App Store
YearlyPremium: $109.99 a year ($9.17/mo)Janitor+: $99.00 a year in the US App Store (about $8.25/mo)
What the plan addsUnlimited messages, 8,000 moments a month, videos and better memory5 times more context, priority replies and monthly swipes with its best models
More optionsUltimate: $39.99 a month or $319.99 a yearRouter on Janitor+, paid per token; or your own model through a proxy
Prices checkedOctober 21, 2026September 2026

Janitor AI’s help center lists no price. Janitor+ renews on its own until you cancel, its terms say. Router credits aren’t refundable, unless the law requires it, its Router page says. Secrets AI’s monthly allowance resets at each renewal and doesn’t roll over. Moments you buy never expire, Secrets AI says. Our pricing traps guide has a cost calculator.

Secrets AI
If you mostly chatAbout $12–22/mo
With lots of pictures or voiceAbout $25–45/mo
From our September 2026 test.
Janitor AI
If you mostly chatAbout $0–13/mo
If you chat a lotAbout $0–13/mo
From our September 2026 test, before any Router or proxy costs.

Test it: Before you add Router or an outside model, check its price per token and set yourself a budget.

Are Secrets AI and Janitor AI safe and private?

Both are real apps for adults, and both are safe enough with common sense. Treat both as cloud chat, not a private diary. Secrets AI scores higher for privacy info (7.6 against 7.2).

Secrets AI and Janitor AI safety and privacy
What to knowSecrets AIJanitor AI
CompanySecret Labs Inc., which lists a Dover, Delaware addressJanitorAI Inc.; its official app is rated 18+ in the App Store
EncryptionEnd-to-end encryption, its homepage says; an AI still has to read your messages to replyIts privacy policy doesn’t promise end-to-end encryption
What it keepsYour chats, memories and pictures stay after you cancel: “Nothing is deleted.”Its privacy policy lists chat conversations, messages and the characters you create
Who checks contentSafety checks can stop some picture and video requests, and those aren’t chargedAutomated systems scan content, and human reviewers check what users flag, its terms say
CancellingSettings, then Manage Subscription; you keep the plan until the period endsOn the web: Settings, then Billing, then Manage Subscription; app plans in the App Store or Google Play
RefundsNo refund for the rest of the periodSubscriptions are generally non-refundable, its subscription FAQ says
DeletingIn account settings; permanent, and all memories are deleted tooSettings, then Security, then Delete account; you can restore it until the scheduled date

Janitor AI’s safety page says it never sells your personal data. People in Australia, Brazil and the UK must pass a one-time age check, its help center says. Secrets AI’s legal page didn’t show its privacy policy or terms when we checked, so read them before you pay. Use a nickname on both.

Sources for Secrets AI, checked October 21, 2026: its homepage and its wiki pages on plans, moments, cancelling and getting started. For Janitor AI: its terms (updated October 8, 2026) and privacy policy (updated September 17, 2026). We also used its community guidelines (updated February 4, 2026), safety page and help center.

Step by step: our free fillable privacy checklist (PDF) and AI girlfriend privacy guide.

Who should pick Secrets AI, and who should pick Janitor AI?

Pick by what you want with your chat: pictures, or lots of characters for free.

Pick Secrets AI if

  • You want pictures and short videos with your adult chat
  • You want one companion, ready-made or built by you
  • You want a polished app (8.1 for app design)

Pick Janitor AI if

  • You want free text roleplay with lots of community characters
  • You want strong price value (8.7): free to start
  • You want to try outside models, like Claude or GPT

For free text roleplay, SpicyChat (7.9) is the closest match to Janitor AI.

Find your match: Secrets AI or Janitor AI?

Six quick rounds of this or that. Pick what sounds more like you, and we’ll match you with the app that scores higher on your picks. It takes about a minute.

Don’t want to play? The short version. Secrets AI leads on pictures and video (8.4 vs 5.8), voice (6.9 vs 5.2) and app design (8.1 vs 7.0). It also edges ahead on privacy info, customization, mobile and NSFW freedom. Janitor AI leads on price value (8.7 vs 7.4). It also edges ahead on chat realism. They tie on memory.

  1. Round 1 of 6 Which would make you smile more?

  2. Round 2 of 6 Which matters more to you?

  3. Round 3 of 6 Pick one for tonight.

  4. Round 4 of 6 Which would you miss more?

  5. Round 5 of 6 Which sounds more like you?

  6. Round 6 of 6 Last one. Which wins?

Bonus: guess the winner

Three close calls from our ratings. Make your guess, then see the real scores.

  1. Who scored higher for chat realism?

  2. Who scored higher for customization?

  3. Who scored higher for mobile?

What are the best alternatives to Secrets AI and Janitor AI?

The best alternative to both for most people is Candy.ai (8.7), if you want selfies and romance fast. These six are ordered by overall score.

More Secrets AI matchups

More Janitor AI matchups

See all comparisons

Secrets AI vs Janitor AI: FAQ

Which is better, Secrets AI or Janitor AI?

Secrets AI, for most people. As of October 2026, it scores 8.1/10 against 7.8/10, and wins on pictures (8.4 against 5.8). Janitor AI wins on price value (8.7 against 7.4).

Is Janitor AI free?

Yes. Its subscription FAQ lists unlimited chats, standard chat models and a context limit of around 9,000 tokens. Janitor AI says it will always keep a free option. Secrets AI’s free plan gives you 20 messages a day.

Which is cheaper, Secrets AI or Janitor AI?

Janitor AI. In our test, it cost about $0–13 a month, against about $12–22 on Secrets AI if you mostly chat. Janitor+ is $12.99 a month, and Secrets AI Premium $19.99.

Which is better for adult roleplay?

Both are built for it: 9.3 for Secrets AI and 9.2 for Janitor AI for NSFW freedom. In Janitor AI’s app, NSFW is off until you switch it on from the website. Check the rules where you live.

Which has pictures and voice calls?

Secrets AI. A picture costs from 50 moments, and calls 50 moments a minute. Janitor AI’s plans don’t list voice calls or a picture maker, its subscription FAQ shows.

Which has better chat?

Janitor AI, by a little: 8.6 for chat realism against 8.3. In our test, two of three free Janitor AI characters stayed in character for 30+ turns. On Secrets AI, our adult roleplay stayed in character for a full half-hour.

Which is more private, Secrets AI or Janitor AI?

Secrets AI scores higher for privacy info: 7.6 against 7.2. Its homepage promises end-to-end encryption. Janitor AI’s privacy policy doesn’t, and its safety page says it never sells your personal data.

Why is Secrets AI ranked #6 and Janitor AI #10?

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. Secrets AI scores 8.1/10, the same as Nomi.ai, which goes first on chat realism, our tie rule. Janitor AI scores 7.8/10, level with HammerAI, Swipey AI and FantasyGF. Janitor AI goes first of those four on chat realism (8.6). A commission never changes a score.

How do I cancel Secrets AI or Janitor+?

On Secrets AI, go to Settings, then Manage Subscription, then Cancel Subscription. For Janitor+ on the web, go to Settings, then Billing, then Manage Subscription. If you subscribed in the Janitor AI app, cancel in the App Store or Google Play.

What’s a good alternative to both?

Candy.ai (8.7), our #1, if you want selfies and romance in minutes. For free text roleplay, SpicyChat (7.9) is the closest match to Janitor AI.

Our verdict: Secrets AI for pictures, Janitor AI for free roleplay

Secrets AI wins overall, 8.1 to 7.8. Pick it for adult chat with pictures, short videos and calls. Pick Janitor AI for free text roleplay with lots of characters and the better price value.

Alex’s take

Start free on both. Try three Janitor AI characters in one evening, and use Secrets AI’s 20 daily messages. Pay only for the one you keep opening.

How we know this

We used both apps through our week-long hands-on test from September 1, 2026, and re-tested both on September 26, 2026. The ten ratings use the same published weights as every app we rank. Secrets AI’s plan prices were checked on October 21, 2026. Janitor AI’s were checked in September 2026, and its App Store prices on October 21, 2026. Facts from each app’s own pages were checked on October 21, 2026.

Comparison updates

  • October 22, 2026: rebuilt the comparison with side-by-side scores, weighted sums and four “which is better” answers. Added prices and privacy facts from both apps’ own pages, the match game and a longer FAQ.
  • October 5, 2026: scores checked against our published weights.
  • September 26, 2026: re-tested both apps.
  • September 1, 2026: first week-long tests of both apps.

Sources

Keep reading

Alex tests every AI girlfriend app we rank for a week and writes our reviews, comparisons and guides. Read Alex’s full bio, or see how Alex tests the apps.

For adults 18+. Adult companion apps are discussed in non-graphic terms. Scores are editorial and dated, and products change.