Adults 18+ only. We earn a commission from some links, but it never changes a score.How we test →
  • Backyard AI: #14 in our ranking
  • Janitor AI: #10 in our ranking
  • Adults 18+

Backyard AI vs Janitor AI (2026): Which Is Better?

Quick verdict

It’s close. As of October 2026, Janitor AI scores 7.8/10 and Backyard AI 7.6/10. Pick Backyard AI if privacy comes first. Pick Janitor AI if you want free roleplay with lots of characters.

Backyard AI has the best privacy score in our ranking (9.2). But Backyard AI says its desktop app is no longer supported.

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. A commission never changes a score.

7.6out of 10
Backyard AIOur pick for privacy#14 of 16 in our ranking
7.8out of 10
Janitor AIBuilt for free character roleplay#10 of 16 in our ranking
Backyard AI and Janitor AI at a glance
At a glanceBackyard AIJanitor AI
Best scorePrivacy info, 9.2NSFW freedom, 9.2
Weakest scoresMobile 5.5, voice 5.5Voice, 5.2
PriceCloud about $12/mo; local was free in our testFree, or $12.99/mo for Janitor+
Free300 cloud messages a weekUnlimited chats, standard models
Where it runsOn your computer, or on its serversIn your browser, or its official app
Watch out forDesktop app no longer supported, Backyard AI saysA short free context limit, around 9,000 tokens
Comparison cardBackyard AI and Janitor AI side by side: the Backyard AI home page on top and the Janitor AI home page below, real screenshots from each site's public pages
Real screens of Backyard AI’s home page (top) and Janitor AI’s home page (bottom), captured October 2026.
On this page

Backyard AI vs Janitor AI in 30 seconds

  • Overall: Janitor AI edges it, 7.8 to 7.6, as of October 2026. They’re #10 and #14 of 16 in our ranking.
  • Janitor AI wins: mobile (7.6 vs 5.5), NSFW freedom (9.2 vs 8.3) and chat realism (8.6 vs 8.0). It also edges ahead on price value and memory.
  • Backyard AI wins: privacy info (9.2 vs 7.2), the best privacy score in our ranking. It also edges ahead on app design, voice and pictures.
  • Real cost: $0 a month on Backyard AI locally, and about $0–13 on Janitor AI, in our September 2026 test.
  • Watch out for: support on Backyard AI. It says its desktop app is no longer supported, and that new paid subscriptions and plan upgrades are currently unavailable.

Scores side by side: who wins what?

Janitor AI wins 5 of the ten ratings and Backyard AI wins 4, with one tie, customization (8.0 each). Janitor AI’s ten ratings work out to 7.78, shown as 7.8. Backyard AI’s work out to 7.57, shown as 7.6. A commission never changes a score.

Backyard AI and Janitor AI scores by rating, out of 10
What we rateWeightBackyard AIJanitor AIHigher score
Overall score7.67.8 (higher)Janitor AI
Chat realism20%8.08.6 (higher)Janitor AI
Customization12%8.0 (tie)8.0 (tie)Tie
NSFW freedom12%8.39.2 (higher)Janitor AI
Memory12%7.57.6 (higher)Janitor AI
Pictures and video10%6.0 (higher)5.8Backyard AI
Price value10%8.58.7 (higher)Janitor AI
App design8%7.5 (higher)7.0Backyard AI
Mobile6%5.57.6 (higher)Janitor AI
Privacy info5%9.2 (higher)7.2Backyard AI
Voice5%5.5 (higher)5.2Backyard AI

Scores out of 10, October 2026. The higher score in each row is in bold pink. Same scores and weights as our ranking and methodology.

Which is better for privacy?

Backyard AI, in local mode. It scores 9.2 for privacy info, the best in our ranking, against 7.2 for Janitor AI.

  • Backyard AI9.2
  • Janitor AI7.2

In our September test, Backyard AI’s desktop app ran a model we downloaded, and chats stayed on our computer. We turned cloud fallback off, so every reply came from our own computer. Cloud chat sends your messages to Backyard AI’s servers.

Janitor AI is cloud chat. Its privacy policy lists chat conversations, messages and the characters you create. Its safety page says it never sells your personal data. Its privacy policy doesn’t promise end-to-end encryption, so use a nickname.

Test it: On Backyard AI, turn cloud fallback off, as we did. Then check where your chats and model files are saved.

Which is better for roleplay?

Janitor AI, by a little. It scores 8.6 for chat realism, against 8.0 for Backyard AI.

  • Backyard AI8.0
  • Janitor AI8.6

On a free Janitor AI account, we opened three community characters in one evening. Two stayed in character for 30+ turns. The third fell into generic replies until we regenerated its answer.

On Backyard AI, we built a character with a lorebook: facts she should always know. Over a 40-turn scene run fully on our computer, she kept her lorebook facts straight. Reply speed tracked the graphics card closely, so it was fine for chatting, but not instant.

Test it: Open three characters on Janitor AI’s free plan in one evening. Keep the one that stays in character for 30 turns.

Which is better for adult roleplay?

Janitor AI. It scores 9.2 for NSFW freedom, against 8.3 for Backyard AI, within each app’s published rules.

  • Backyard AI8.3
  • Janitor AI9.2

Janitor AI’s guidelines allow adult content between consenting adult characters, with some themes banned. Characters with sexual or romantic themes must be tagged Limitless. In its phone app, NSFW stays off until you switch it on from the website.

Backyard AI says it doesn’t censor or filter text model generations. Its hub rules say characters with explicit language or imagery must be marked as mature content. They must all portray adults over 18. Check the rules where you live.

Test it: Using Janitor AI’s app? Switch on “Enable NSFW for App” in the website’s Settings, then close the app and open it again.

Which is better on your phone?

Janitor AI. It scores 7.6 for mobile, against 5.5 for Backyard AI.

  • Backyard AI5.5
  • Janitor AI7.6

On iPhone, Janitor AI’s official app is Janitor: Interactive Stories, from the developer JanitorAI, rated 18+ in the App Store. The app keeps NSFW off at first to meet App Store and Google Play rules, its help center says.

Backyard AI’s iPhone app is listed by Ahoy Labs, Inc., on the App Store, and its site links to an Android app on Google Play. Our test used its desktop app, and we haven’t tested the phone apps yet.

Backyard AI vs Janitor AI pricing: which costs less?

Janitor+ costs $12.99 a month in the US App Store, and Backyard AI’s cloud plans about $12 or $35 a month. In our test, Backyard AI cost $0 a month locally, and Janitor AI about $0–13 a month. Janitor AI scores a little higher for price value (8.7 against 8.5). Backyard AI says new paid subscriptions and plan upgrades are currently unavailable. Confirm prices at checkout: they change.

Backyard AI and Janitor AI prices
Plans and costsBackyard AIJanitor AI
FreeLocal chat cost nothing in our test, plus 300 free cloud messages a weekUnlimited chats, standard chat models and a context limit of around 9,000 tokens
Main planCloud Standard: about $12 a month, or about $9 a month yearlyJanitor+: $12.99 a month, with 5 times more context and priority replies
Bigger or longer plansCloud Pro: about $35 a month, or about $26 a month yearly$99.00 a year in the US App Store (about $8.25 a month, by our math)
ExtrasModel files take up storage, and running them uses powerRouter, billed per token on Janitor+, or an outside model through a proxy
New sign-upsNew paid subscriptions currently unavailable, Backyard AI saysJanitor+ renews on its own until you cancel, its terms say
Prices checkedSeptember 2026September 2026

Our September prices for Backyard AI match its App Store listing: $12.00 for Cloud Standard and $34.99 for Cloud Pro. Janitor AI’s help center lists no price, so its prices come from the US App Store, checked October 21, 2026. Janitor AI’s real cost is before any Router or proxy costs. Router credits aren’t refundable, unless the law requires it, its Router page says. Our pricing traps guide has a cost calculator.

Backyard AI
If you chat locally$0/mo
With cloud modelsAbout $9–35/mo
From our September 2026 test.
Janitor AI
If you mostly chatAbout $0–13/mo
If you chat a lotAbout $0–13/mo
From our September 2026 test.

Test it: On Backyard AI, check your free storage before you download a model. On Janitor AI, check a model’s price per token before you add Router.

Are Backyard AI and Janitor AI safe and private?

Both are real apps for adults 18+, and both are safe enough with care. Backyard AI scores higher for privacy info (9.2 against 7.2), but its desktop app no longer gets support, it says. Treat Janitor AI as cloud chat, not a private diary.

Backyard AI and Janitor AI safety and privacy
What to knowBackyard AIJanitor AI
CompanyAhoy Labs, Inc.; its terms are governed by California lawJanitorAI Inc.; its official app is rated 18+ in the App Store
Where chats goIn local mode, our test chats never left the computer; cloud chat goes to its serversIts privacy policy lists chat conversations, messages and the characters you create
Who else may see itIts privacy policy doesn’t mention chats, and says it may share your information with business partnersAutomated systems scan content, and human reviewers check content that users flag, its terms say
SecurityIts plans page says it uses “industry-standard encryption”; its download page says the desktop app is “deprecated and no longer supported”Its privacy policy doesn’t promise end-to-end encryption; its safety page says it never sells your personal data
Age checksThe site is intended for users who are at least 18, its terms sayIn Australia, Brazil and the UK, a one-time age check run by k-ID; Janitor AI only learns if you’re over 18
CancellingAny time on the Manage Subscription page, or by email; it takes effect at the end of the paid termOn the web: Settings, then Billing, then Manage Subscription; app plans cancel in the App Store or Google Play
RefundsIts terms don’t promise refundsSubscriptions are generally non-refundable, its subscription FAQ says
DeletingIts privacy policy explains how to ask for deletionSettings, then Security, then Delete account, with a 6-digit code; the account is deactivated first, then deleted on the scheduled date

Sources for Backyard AI, checked October 21, 2026: its plans page, terms and privacy policy (both updated October 29, 2024), and desktop download page. For Janitor AI: its terms (updated October 8, 2026), privacy policy (updated September 17, 2026), safety page and subscription FAQ. We also used its help center pages on age checks and deleting your account.

Step by step: our free fillable privacy checklist (PDF) and AI girlfriend privacy guide.

Who should pick Backyard AI, and who should pick Janitor AI?

Pick by where you want to chat: privately on your own computer, or with lots of free characters anywhere.

Pick Backyard AI if

  • Privacy comes first, and you have a capable computer
  • You want long stories, with a lorebook of facts she should always know
  • You want local chat at no cost ($0 a month in our test)

Pick Janitor AI if

  • You want free text roleplay with lots of community characters
  • You want the more open adult roleplay of the two (9.2 for NSFW freedom)
  • You want to chat on your phone, in its official app

Skip both if you mainly want selfies. Candy.ai (8.7) is our #1, and its pictures beat both.

Find your match: Backyard AI or Janitor AI?

Six quick rounds of this or that. Pick what sounds more like you, and we’ll match you with the app that scores higher on your picks. It takes about a minute.

Don’t want to play? The short version. Backyard AI leads on privacy info (9.2 vs 7.2) and app design (7.5 vs 7.0). It also edges ahead on voice and pictures and video. Janitor AI leads on mobile (7.6 vs 5.5), NSFW freedom (9.2 vs 8.3) and chat realism (8.6 vs 8.0). It also edges ahead on price value and memory. They tie on customization.

  1. Round 1 of 6 Which would make you smile more?

  2. Round 2 of 6 Which matters more to you?

  3. Round 3 of 6 Pick one for tonight.

  4. Round 4 of 6 Which would you miss more?

  5. Round 5 of 6 Which sounds more like you?

  6. Round 6 of 6 Last one. Which wins?

Bonus: guess the winner

Three close calls from our ratings. Make your guess, then see the real scores.

  1. Who scored higher for memory?

  2. Who scored higher for price value?

  3. Who scored higher for pictures and video?

What are the best alternatives to Backyard AI and Janitor AI?

The best alternative to both for most people is Candy.ai (8.7), if you want selfies and romance fast. For privacy, HammerAI (7.8) is the closest match to Backyard AI. For free text roleplay, SpicyChat (7.9) is the closest match to Janitor AI. These six are ordered by overall score.

More Backyard AI matchups

More Janitor AI matchups

See all comparisons

Backyard AI vs Janitor AI: FAQ

Which is better, Backyard AI or Janitor AI?

It’s close, and it depends on what you want. As of October 2026, Janitor AI scores 7.8/10 and wins on chat realism (8.6 against 8.0). Backyard AI scores 7.6/10 and wins on privacy info (9.2 against 7.2).

Which is more private, Backyard AI or Janitor AI?

Backyard AI, in local mode: it has the top privacy score in our ranking (9.2). In our test, local chats stayed on our computer. Janitor AI’s privacy policy lists your chats among the data it collects.

Which is better for free roleplay?

Janitor AI, for most people. Its free plan includes unlimited chats, and two of our three free characters stayed in character for 30+ turns. Backyard AI’s local mode was free in our test, but it needs a capable computer.

Which is better for adult roleplay?

Janitor AI: 9.2 for NSFW freedom, against 8.3 for Backyard AI. In Janitor AI’s app, NSFW is off until you switch it on in Settings on the website. Check the rules where you live.

Which remembers more, Backyard AI or Janitor AI?

They’re close: 7.6 for Janitor AI and 7.5 for Backyard AI. In our test, Backyard AI kept its lorebook facts straight for 40 turns. Janitor AI’s free plan has a context limit of around 9,000 tokens.

Is Backyard AI still supported?

Its desktop app isn’t. Its download page says the desktop app is “deprecated and no longer supported,” and points you to backyard.ai. Mac and Windows downloads were still listed when we checked on October 21, 2026.

Are Backyard AI and Janitor AI free?

Yes, both. In our test, Backyard AI’s local mode cost nothing, and it offers 300 free cloud messages a week. Janitor AI’s free plan includes unlimited chats on standard models, and Janitor AI says it will always keep a free option.

Why is Backyard AI ranked #14 and Janitor AI #10?

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. Janitor AI scores 7.8 and ties with HammerAI (7.8), Swipey AI (7.8) and FantasyGF (7.8). Janitor AI goes first on chat realism (8.6), our tie rule. Backyard AI scores 7.6, and no other app shares that score. A commission never changes a score.

How do I cancel Backyard AI or Janitor+?

On Backyard AI, cancel on the Manage Subscription page, or by email, its plans page says. For Janitor+ on the web, go to Settings, then Billing, then Manage Subscription. If you subscribed in its app, cancel in the App Store or Google Play.

What’s a good alternative to both?

Candy.ai (8.7), our #1, if you want selfies and romance in minutes. For lots of free text roleplay, try SpicyChat (7.9).

Our verdict: Janitor AI for free roleplay, Backyard AI for privacy

Janitor AI edges it overall, 7.8 to 7.6. Pick it if you want free roleplay with lots of characters: it has the more open adult chat and a higher mobile score. Pick Backyard AI if privacy is the whole point. It has the best privacy score in our ranking, but its desktop app no longer gets support, it says.

Alex’s take

Start free on Janitor AI and try three characters in one evening. Choose Backyard AI only if privacy is the whole point, and keep cloud fallback off, as we did.

How we know this

We used both apps through our week-long hands-on test from September 1, 2026, and re-tested both on September 26, 2026. The ten ratings use the same published weights as every app we rank. Backyard AI’s prices were checked in September 2026, and Janitor AI’s in September 2026. Facts from each app’s own pages, and Janitor AI’s App Store prices, were checked on October 21, 2026.

Comparison updates

  • October 22, 2026: rebuilt the comparison with side-by-side scores, weighted sums and four “which is better” answers. Added prices and privacy facts from both apps’ own pages, the match game and a longer FAQ.
  • October 5, 2026: scores checked against our published weights.
  • September 26, 2026: re-tested both apps.
  • September 1, 2026: first week-long tests of both apps.

Sources

Keep reading

Alex tests every AI girlfriend app we rank for a week and writes our reviews, comparisons and guides. Read Alex’s full bio, or see how Alex tests the apps.

For adults 18+. Adult companion apps are discussed in non-graphic terms. Scores are editorial and dated, and products change.