Adults 18+ only. We earn a commission from some links, but it never changes a score.How we test →
  • Trust list
  • Adults 18+

AI Girlfriend Apps We Don’t Recommend

Seven brands we leave out of our ranking for trust reasons, the reason for each, and what to use instead.

Quick answer

As of October 2026, we don’t recommend seven AI girlfriend apps: four we removed and three we never added.

We removed GirlfriendGPT, Romantic AI, Eva AI and Kupid AI. We skipped Muah AI, CrushOn.ai and GPTGirlfriend. These are trust decisions, not legal findings.

We do not invent new allegations here, only reasons already in our records.

Seven apps, left out for trust reasons

Each one is named with the reason from our records, and an app we rank instead.

Removed
4 apps, September 26, 2026
Never added
3 apps
Main reasons
Phishing, privacy, billing
Use instead
Kindroid, Nomi.ai, Character.AI
Kind of decision
Trust, not legal findings
Apps we rank
16
Page coverAI girlfriend apps we don’t recommend: a phone with one app crossed out, a shield with a cross and a See why button
Seven apps we leave out, and why. October 2026.
On this page

Apps we don’t recommend in 30 seconds

  • Four removed: GirlfriendGPT, Romantic AI, Eva AI and Kupid AI left our ranking on September 26, 2026.
  • Three never added: we skipped Muah AI, CrushOn.ai and GPTGirlfriend in the same refresh.
  • The reasons: phishing reports, privacy and tracking concerns, outside privacy warnings, billing risk and a data breach.
  • Not for sale: apps can’t pay for a review or a score, and some brands stay out even if they pay affiliates.
  • Use instead: Kindroid, Nomi.ai, Character.AI or Janitor AI, depending on what you wanted.

Which apps don’t we recommend, and why?

We don’t recommend seven apps. Here is each one, with the reason from our records and an app we rank instead.

The seven AI girlfriend apps we don’t recommend: decision, reason and what to use instead
AppDecisionWhyInstead
GirlfriendGPTRemoved, September 26, 2026Phishing and related trust-risk reportsKindroid
Romantic AIRemoved, September 26, 2026Privacy and tracking concerns found in our trust checksNomi.ai
Eva AIRemoved, September 26, 2026Flagged by Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included for aggressive data practicesCharacter.AI or Janitor AI
Kupid AIRemoved, September 26, 2026Billing risk in our trust notes, linked to weekly billing and chargeback patternsCharacter.AI
Muah AINever added, September 2026A data breach in 2024See our ranking
CrushOn.aiNever added, September 2026Privacy concerns, with a Mozilla Privacy Not Included warningSee our ranking
GPTGirlfriendNever added, September 2026Grouped with GirlfriendGPT in the same trust decisionSee our ranking

Listed in the order of our records, not ranked. These are trust decisions, not legal findings.

Why don’t we recommend GirlfriendGPT?

We removed GirlfriendGPT in our September 2026 trust and safety refresh, after phishing and related trust-risk reports. Our old review links for it now go to our Kindroid review.

We also skipped GPTGirlfriend in the same trust decision.

Instead: Kindroid (8.8 for voice) is our pick for voice calls.

Source: our trust records, dated in the ranking changelog entry of September 26, 2026.

Why don’t we recommend Romantic AI?

We removed Romantic AI over privacy and tracking concerns found in our trust checks. For soft romance, Nomi.ai covers it better on our list.

Instead: Nomi.ai (9.0 for memory) is our pick for memory.

Source: our trust checks of September 2026, dated in the ranking changelog entry of September 26, 2026.

Why don’t we recommend Eva AI?

We removed Eva AI after Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide flagged its aggressive data practices. For roleplay with a big character library, see Character.AI or Janitor AI.

Instead: Character.AI, built for safe-for-work character chat, or Janitor AI, built for free character roleplay.

Our PolyBuzz review stays published, but PolyBuzz isn’t ranked. A review is not a privacy guarantee.

Source: Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide, as recorded in our September 2026 trust check. Our PolyBuzz review lists an archived copy of that entry in its sources.

Why don’t we recommend Kupid AI?

We removed Kupid AI over billing risk in our trust notes, linked to weekly billing and chargeback patterns. For safe-for-work character chat, see Character.AI instead.

Instead: Character.AI, built for safe-for-work character chat.

Source: our trust notes, dated in the ranking changelog entry of September 26, 2026.

Which apps did we never add?

We never added three apps: Muah AI, CrushOn.ai and GPTGirlfriend. We skipped them in the same September 2026 refresh, so none was ever ranked.

  • Muah AI: a data breach in 2024.
  • CrushOn.ai: privacy concerns, with a warning in Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide.
  • GPTGirlfriend: grouped with GirlfriendGPT in the same trust decision.

Confirm the live shortlist on our homepage ranking.

How do we decide which apps to leave out?

We leave an app out when our checks or outside reports point to a real risk for you. So far, five kinds of risk have led to a decision.

  1. Phishing reports, as with GirlfriendGPT.
  2. Privacy or tracking problems found in our own trust checks, as with Romantic AI.
  3. An outside privacy warning, such as Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included, as with Eva AI and CrushOn.ai.
  4. Billing risk, such as weekly billing and chargeback patterns, as with Kupid AI.
  5. A data breach, as with Muah AI in 2024.

Apps can’t pay for a review or a score. Some brands stay out for trust reasons, even if they pay affiliates.

Every app we do rank gets the same ten ratings and 7-day test.

What would change our mind?

A fix we can check ourselves. If an app shows the problem is gone, we can look at it again.

  • The app’s own pages explain clearly what it keeps and how to delete it.
  • Billing is plain: the price, the renewal and how to cancel are clear before you pay.
  • No new phishing, breach or privacy reports since our decision.
  • It passes the same 7-day test that every ranked app gets.

Until then, it stays on this list and out of our ranking. Any change would be dated in our ranking changelog.

Apps we don’t recommend: FAQ

Why don’t you recommend GirlfriendGPT?

We removed it in our September 2026 trust and safety refresh, after phishing and related trust-risk reports. Kindroid is the app we suggest instead.

Why did you remove Romantic AI?

Over privacy and tracking concerns found in our trust checks. For soft romance, Nomi.ai covers it better on our list.

Why did you remove Eva AI?

Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide flagged its aggressive data practices. We removed it on September 26, 2026.

Why did you remove Kupid AI?

Over billing risk in our trust notes, linked to weekly billing and chargeback patterns. For safe-for-work character chat, try Character.AI instead.

Why didn’t you add Muah AI or CrushOn.ai?

Muah AI had a data breach in 2024. CrushOn.ai raised privacy concerns, with a warning in Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide.

Can an app pay to be recommended?

No. Apps can’t pay for a review or a score. Some brands stay out for trust reasons, even if they pay affiliates.

Could a removed app come back?

Yes, if it fixes the problem and we can check the fix ourselves. It would then get our full 7-day test, and the change would be dated in our changelog.

Is PolyBuzz on this list?

No. PolyBuzz left our ranking on October 1, 2026, because its character library overlaps with Character.AI and Janitor AI. That was not a trust or safety decision, and its review stays published.

The bottom line

Seven apps stay out of our ranking for trust reasons. If you came looking for one of them, start with the app we suggest instead. Then check its privacy page before you pay.

How we know this

Every reason on this page comes from our records of the September 2026 trust refresh, as our live page stated them on October 22, 2026. We do not add new allegations here. Questions or corrections: hello@bestaigirlfriendhub.com.

Page updates

  • October 23, 2026: rebuilt with the reason and source for each app, how we decide, what would change our mind and what to use instead.
  • October 8, 2026: the previous version: the four removed apps and the three we skipped.

Sources

  • Our ranking changelog, entry of September 26, 2026: the four removals and the apps we didn’t add.
  • Our trust records from the September 2026 refresh: the reason behind each decision.
  • Mozilla’s Privacy Not Included guide: named for Eva AI and CrushOn.ai. Our PolyBuzz review lists an archived copy of its Eva AI entry.
  • Our AI girlfriend privacy guide: it links the Muah.AI breach record and Mozilla’s privacy findings.

Keep reading

Alex tests every AI girlfriend app we rank for a week and writes our reviews, comparisons and guides. Read Alex’s full bio, or see how Alex tests the apps.

For adults 18+. Updates: October 23, 2026: rebuilt with the reason and source for each app, how we decide and what would change our mind.