Adults 18+ only. We earn a commission from some links, but it never changes a score.How we test →
  • Secrets AI: #6 in our ranking
  • Replika: #15 in our ranking
  • Adults 18+

Secrets AI vs Replika (2026): Which Is Better?

Quick verdict

As of October 2026, Secrets AI scores 8.1/10 and Replika 7.3/10. Pick Secrets AI if you want open adult chat with pictures. Pick Replika if you want a calm, caring friend on your phone.

Replika has the top mobile score in our ranking (8.8). Secrets AI is far more open for adult chat (9.3 against 5.5).

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. A commission never changes a score.

8.1out of 10
Secrets AIBuilt for open adult chat#6 of 16 in our ranking
7.3out of 10
ReplikaBuilt for a calm, caring friend#15 of 16 in our ranking
Secrets AI and Replika at a glance
At a glanceSecrets AIReplika
Best scoreNSFW freedom, 9.3Mobile, 8.8
Weakest scoreVoice, 6.9NSFW freedom, 5.5
PriceFrom $19.99/mo, or $9.17/mo yearlyFrom $7.99/mo (US App Store)
Free20 messages a dayChat is free, no trial
Voice calls50 moments a minuteVoice calls on Pro
RomanceOpen adult chat, with a Spice Level in each chatRomantic Partner status on Pro
Comparison cardSecrets AI and Replika side by side: the Secrets AI character builder on top and the Replika chat preview below, real screenshots from each site's public pages
Real screens of Secrets AI’s character builder (top) and Replika’s chat preview (bottom), captured October 2026.
On this page

Secrets AI vs Replika in 30 seconds

  • Overall: Secrets AI leads, 8.1 to 7.3, as of October 2026. They’re #6 and #15 of 16 in our ranking.
  • Secrets AI wins: NSFW freedom (9.3 vs 5.5), pictures (8.4 vs 6.0) and customization (8.2 vs 7.0). It also edges ahead on chat realism, price value and app design.
  • Replika wins: voice (8.2 vs 6.9), mobile (8.8 vs 7.8) and memory (8.2 vs 7.6), plus a hair more on privacy info.
  • Real cost: about $12–22 a month on Secrets AI if you mostly chat. Replika’s chat is free, and Pro costs from $7.99 a month, from our September 2026 check.
  • Skip both if: you want the best memory. Nomi.ai (9.0 for memory) is our pick for memory.

Scores side by side: who wins what?

Secrets AI wins 6 of the ten ratings and Replika wins 4. Secrets AI’s ten ratings work out to 8.09, shown as 8.1. Replika’s work out to 7.25, shown as 7.3. A commission never changes a score.

Secrets AI and Replika scores by rating, out of 10
What we rateWeightSecrets AIReplikaHigher score
Overall score8.1 (higher)7.3Secrets AI
Chat realism20%8.3 (higher)7.5Secrets AI
Customization12%8.2 (higher)7.0Secrets AI
NSFW freedom12%9.3 (higher)5.5Secrets AI
Memory12%7.68.2 (higher)Replika
Pictures and video10%8.4 (higher)6.0Secrets AI
Price value10%7.4 (higher)7.0Secrets AI
App design8%8.1 (higher)8.0Secrets AI
Mobile6%7.88.8 (higher)Replika
Privacy info5%7.67.8 (higher)Replika
Voice5%6.98.2 (higher)Replika

Scores out of 10, October 2026. The higher score in each row is in bold pink. Same scores and weights as our ranking and methodology.

Which is better for adult roleplay?

Secrets AI, by a wide margin. It scores 9.3 for NSFW freedom against 5.5 for Replika.

  • Secrets AI9.3
  • Replika5.5

In our test, Secrets AI stayed in character through a half-hour adult roleplay. Each chat has a Spice Level, Secrets AI says. Safety checks can still stop some picture and video requests, and those aren’t charged.

Replika is built for friendship first. On Pro, you can set her relationship status to Romantic Partner, Replika says. In our checks, romantic mode depended on account and region settings. Even on Pro, the tone stayed friendship-first.

Test it: Chat free on Replika for a week before you pay. Note whether romantic mode is offered on your account.

Which is better for pictures?

Secrets AI. It scores 8.4 for pictures and video against 6.0 for Replika.

  • Secrets AI8.4
  • Replika6.0

A Secrets AI picture costs from 50 moments, or 100 in 2K, Secrets AI says. Premium and up can turn a picture into a short clip, most 4 to 15 seconds, its video page says.

On Replika, Pro unblurs romantic selfies and adds image generation. Platinum adds up to 10 selfie videos, its help center says. We haven’t tested Platinum yet.

Test it: Make one picture and one short video on Secrets AI. Check your moments.

Which is better for voice calls?

Replika. It scores 8.2 for voice against 6.9 for Secrets AI, its weakest rating.

  • Secrets AI6.9
  • Replika8.2

Replika Pro adds voice messages, background calls, premium voices and roleplay in voice and AR calls, Replika says. In our test, her AR avatar felt more present on the phone than most web companions.

Secrets AI has real-time calls at 50 moments a minute, with no time limit, Secrets AI says. Kindroid has the best voice score in our ranking (8.8 for voice), and it’s our pick for voice calls.

Test it: Make a short voice call on each app. Note how natural it feels.

Which is better for customizing her?

Secrets AI. It scores 8.2 for customization against 7.0 for Replika.

  • Secrets AI8.2
  • Replika7.0

On Secrets AI, you pick her looks, realistic or anime, plus voice, personality and backstory. The first companion is free, then 500 moments each, Secrets AI says.

Replika is built around one AI friend, called your Rep. You dress her and decorate her room with coins and gems. You earn them as you go, and can also buy gems, Replika says.

Test it: Build your own companion on Secrets AI. The first one is free.

Secrets AI vs Replika pricing: which costs less?

Replika’s chat is free, and its paid plans start at $7.99 a month in the US App Store. Secrets AI Premium costs $19.99 a month. In our test, mostly chatting cost about $12–22 a month on Secrets AI, and from $7.99 on Replika with Pro. Secrets AI scores a little higher for price value (7.4 against 7.0). Confirm prices at checkout: they change.

Secrets AI and Replika prices
Plans and costsSecrets AIReplika
Free20 messages a day and a small starting balance of moments; you can’t buy moreChat with your Replika for free; there’s no free trial of the paid plans
Main planPremium: $19.99 a month, or $109.99 a year ($9.17/mo)Monthly: $7.99 or $14.99 in the US App Store
Longer plansUltimate: $39.99 a month, or $319.99 a year ($26.67/mo)Yearly: $49.99–$69.99; Platinum: $89.99
What paid addsUnlimited messages, 8,000 moments a month, videos and better memoryPro: Romantic Partner status, unblurred selfies, image generation, premium voices and voice calls
ExtrasMoments: from 50 per picture, 600 to 1,200 per 5-second video, 50 per call minuteCoins and gems for her looks, clothes and room; you can also buy gems
Prices checkedOctober 21, 2026September 2026

Replika doesn’t publish prices on its site. The cost shows in the app and the store, its help center says, and Replika offers Ultra as an annual plan. Secrets AI’s monthly allowance resets at each renewal. Moments you buy never expire, Secrets AI says. Our pricing traps guide has a cost calculator.

Secrets AI
If you mostly chatAbout $12–22/mo
With lots of pictures or voiceAbout $25–45/mo
From our September 2026 test.
Replika
If you mostly chat, with ProFrom $7.99/mo
With lots of pictures or voice, plus gems or Platinum$7.99–$14.99/mo
From our September 2026 test.

Test it: Before you pay, open the subscription screen. Note the plan, the price and the renewal date.

Are Secrets AI and Replika safe and private?

Both are real paid apps for adults 18+, and both are safe enough with common sense. Use a nickname on both. Replika scores a little higher for privacy info (7.8 against 7.6).

Secrets AI and Replika safety and privacy
What to knowSecrets AIReplika
CompanySecret Labs Inc., which lists a Dover, Delaware addressLuka, Inc., based in San Francisco
EncryptionIts homepage says chats are protected with end-to-end encryptionData is encrypted in transit; it doesn’t promise end-to-end encryption
How chats are usedAn AI still reads your messages to reply; its privacy policy wasn’t on its legal pageSmall parts of messages train its safety systems; it never shares chats with advertising partners
CancellingSettings, then Manage Subscription; your chats, memories and pictures staySettings, then Subscription, or the store you paid through; deleting the app doesn’t cancel
RefundsNo refund for the rest of the period; you keep your plan until it endsPurchases are final, Replika says; Apple or Google handle store refunds
DeletingIn account settings; permanent, and all memories are deleted tooPermanent, and it erases chat history and photos. Messages are kept up to 60 days after the contract ends.

Sources for Secrets AI, checked October 21, 2026: its homepage and its wiki pages on plans, moments and cancelling. Its legal page didn’t show its privacy policy or terms, so read them before you pay. For Replika: its privacy policy (updated May 27, 2026), terms (updated March 30, 2026) and help center on deleting your account and billing after deleting. In a crisis, its terms say to stop using it and call 911.

Step by step: our free fillable privacy checklist (PDF) and AI girlfriend privacy guide.

Who should pick Secrets AI, and who should pick Replika?

Pick by the company you want: an open adult roleplay partner, or a calm friend who checks in.

Pick Secrets AI if

  • You want open adult roleplay with pictures and short videos
  • You want to build your own companion, realistic or anime
  • You want more freedom in chat (9.3 for NSFW freedom)

Pick Replika if

  • You want a calm, caring friend who checks in on you
  • You want polished phone apps, with an AR avatar
  • You want to chat free, with paid extras only if you want them

Skip both if you want the best memory. Nomi.ai (9.0 for memory) is our pick for memory.

Find your match: Secrets AI or Replika?

Six quick rounds of this or that. Pick what sounds more like you, and we’ll match you with the app that scores higher on your picks. It takes about a minute.

Don’t want to play? The short version. Secrets AI leads on NSFW freedom (9.3 vs 5.5), pictures and video (8.4 vs 6.0) and customization (8.2 vs 7.0). It also leads on chat realism, price value and app design. Replika leads on voice (8.2 vs 6.9), mobile (8.8 vs 7.8) and memory (8.2 vs 7.6). It also edges ahead on privacy info.

  1. Round 1 of 6 Which would make you smile more?

  2. Round 2 of 6 Which matters more to you?

  3. Round 3 of 6 Pick one for tonight.

  4. Round 4 of 6 Which would you miss more?

  5. Round 5 of 6 Which sounds more like you?

  6. Round 6 of 6 Last one. Which wins?

Bonus: guess the winner

Three close calls from our ratings. Make your guess, then see the real scores.

  1. Who scored higher for price value?

  2. Who scored higher for app design?

  3. Who scored higher for privacy info?

What are the best alternatives to Secrets AI and Replika?

The best alternative to both for most people is Candy.ai (8.7), if you want romance with selfies. For a caring companion with the best memory, Nomi.ai (8.1) is the closest match. These six are ordered by overall score.

More Secrets AI matchups

More Replika matchups

See all comparisons

Secrets AI vs Replika: FAQ

Which is better, Secrets AI or Replika?

It depends on what you want. As of October 2026, Secrets AI scores 8.1/10 and wins on adult chat (9.3 against 5.5 for NSFW freedom). Replika scores 7.3/10 and wins on phone apps and voice.

Which is better for adult roleplay?

Secrets AI. It scores 9.3 for NSFW freedom against 5.5 for Replika. In our test, it stayed in character through a half-hour adult roleplay. Check the rules where you live.

Can Replika be your girlfriend?

Yes, on Pro: you can set her relationship status to Romantic Partner, Replika says. In our checks, romantic mode depended on account and region settings. Adult chat is limited (5.5 for NSFW freedom).

Which has better voice calls?

Replika. It scores 8.2 for voice against 6.9 for Secrets AI. Pro adds voice messages, background calls and roleplay in voice and AR calls, Replika says. Kindroid has our best voice score.

Which is cheaper, Secrets AI or Replika?

Replika, mostly. Its chat is free, and paid plans start at $7.99 a month in the US App Store. Secrets AI Premium is $19.99 a month. In our test, mostly chatting cost about $12–22 on Secrets AI and from $7.99 on Replika with Pro.

Are Secrets AI and Replika free?

Both have a free start. Secrets AI gives you 20 messages a day, and free users can’t buy moments. Chatting with your Replika is free, but there’s no free trial of its paid plans.

Which is more private, Secrets AI or Replika?

Replika scores a little higher for privacy info (7.8 against 7.6). Its privacy policy says chats are never shared with advertising partners. Secrets AI’s legal page didn’t show a privacy policy when we checked.

Can Replika replace therapy?

No. Its terms say Replika isn’t medical or mental health care, and isn’t for emergencies. In a crisis, they say to stop using it and call 911.

Why is Secrets AI ranked #6 and Replika #15?

Apps are listed by overall score, with one editorial exception: OurDream AI is placed at #2 as our pick for building her yourself. OurDream AI is an affiliate partner. Secrets AI scores 8.1, the same as Nomi.ai, and Nomi.ai goes first on chat realism, our tie rule. Replika scores 7.3, and no other app has that score. Character.AI (7.2) is the only app below it. A commission never changes a score.

How do I cancel Secrets AI or Replika?

On Secrets AI, go to Settings, then Manage Subscription, then Cancel Subscription. On Replika, go to Settings, then Subscription, then Cancel subscription. If you paid through Apple, Google or PayPal, cancel it there.

Our verdict: Secrets AI for adult chat, Replika for a calm friend

Secrets AI scores higher overall, 8.1 to 7.3. Pick it if you want open adult roleplay: it has far more freedom, better pictures and short videos. Pick Replika if you want a calm, caring friend: it has the best phone apps in our ranking and the better voice.

Alex’s take

Chat free on Replika for a week, and use Secrets AI’s free 20 messages a day. Then pay for one month of the one you open first, not a year.

How we know this

We used both apps through our week-long hands-on test from September 1, 2026, and re-tested both on September 26, 2026. The ten ratings use the same published weights as every app we rank. Secrets AI’s prices were checked on October 21, 2026. Replika’s come from our US App Store check in September 2026. Facts from each app’s own pages were checked on October 21, 2026.

Comparison updates

  • October 22, 2026: rebuilt the comparison with side-by-side scores, weighted sums and four “which is better” answers. Added prices and privacy facts from both apps’ own pages, the match game and a longer FAQ.
  • October 5, 2026: scores checked against our published weights.
  • September 26, 2026: re-tested both apps.
  • September 1, 2026: first week-long tests of both apps.

Sources

Keep reading

Alex tests every AI girlfriend app we rank for a week and writes our reviews, comparisons and guides. Read Alex’s full bio, or see how Alex tests the apps.

For adults 18+. Adult companion apps are discussed in non-graphic terms. Scores are editorial and dated, and products change.